Saturday, July 18, 2009

Pricing:
Introduction: Pricing is to put price on a product which determines whether we will be able to sell a product or sustain manufacturing in long term (if price is below legitimate profit then one may not be able to survive). Pricing proposal should be derived from the goal of the company, which as stated in book “The Goal” is:
“To make money by increasing net profit, while simultaneously increasing return on investment and simultaneously increasing cash flow.”

Potential constraints of the system are:
1) Market: Eg. Because of high competition, low cost (Chinese) competitors and other reasons market is not allowing to put higher margin that we may want.
2) Factors of production: There are 2 fundamental factors of production: Capital and Labor. Pricing should take into account both these factors.

Manner in which these variables are related it as follows: As we can see in the pricing structure below, there is floor price (we cannot go below that) and ceiling price (market will not allow us to go up this). Factors of production define floor price and market determines ceiling price.


We need to find out both prices for our product before setting the final price.

A) If ceiling price (CP) > floor price (FP), then we may modify our offer to achieve company objective.

B) If ceiling price (CP) < (FP) then no bid or strategic offer

But it is not always possible to know what is CP (lack of information). And in these products, if we don’t have target price from customer, comparison from competition or previous experience, then we may not be able to decide what market expectations are. In those cases, we need to determine overall margin for that proposal and check if it agrees with price from production factors or not.

1) Deciding CP: Straight forward method will be to get target price form customer or getting competition price for same product or decide it on basis of past experience. But as we said before, it is not always possible to get it. In its absence, next logical step is to find out overall margin (OM) on the product. Overall Margin (OM) is the margin which indicates how much premium we are putting on our services for a particular customer order. Attempt is to list down exhaustive and mutually non-exclusive criteria so that we can come-up with some formula to decide overall margin:

i) competition present for that particular RFQ (say a)

ii) strategic importance of customer/ RFQ (say b)

iii) industry norm for that product line (industry in which customer operates) (say c)

iv) previous history with that customer (say d)

Now if we have properly analyzed all the above parameters, we can define OM for an RFQ. We need to assign weightage to each parameter to calculate the overall margin. Also we may give scales on which these parameters have to be rated.

i) Competition: Let’s rate competition for an RFQ on scale of 1 to 10. Since increase in competition means lesser margin, we will give lower marks for higher competition and vice-versa. Weightage = 40%

CHECK LIST (TO BE ANSWERED) BEFORE DECIDING THE MARKS

How fierce is competition for this order?

What are standard rates for similar products (if available in market)?

What is the size of nearest competitor? (if known)

Is it single tender basis or only by invitation or open tender?

Is there any target price set for the order?

ii) Strategy: Does customer fit in GOAL’s overall strategy? How important it is to get that order? We will rate this parameter again on 1-10 scale. If customer / Order is more important than we will give lower Mark and consequently lesser margins). Weight = 30%

CHECK LIST (TO BE ANSWERED) BEFORE DECIDING THE MARK

Do we have enough capacity to carry out this order?

Do we have enough technical know-how for this order?

How important this customer is in my long term growth strategy?

Will this customer give us entry into totally new market?

Will this order give us entry into totally new product line?

Is this long term customer or new customer?

Is it budgetary offer or RFQ?

iii) Industry: Industry in which customer is operating will impact our margins. For example if it is semi-conductor industry, where margins are very low, then we may not able to quote higher margin. We will rate this factor on the basis of favorability (unfavorable). If it favorable to us we will we will give more mark otherwise fewer. Scale will be defined 1 to 10. For neutral (or no information) we will give 5 marks. Weight = 10%

CHECK LIST (TO BE ANSWERED) BEFORE DECING THE MARK

Is this industry, price sensitive?

What are average margins for enquired product in customer’s industry?

Is value of our supply big part of customer’s end product cost?

Is quality of our supply very important for customer’s end product?

iv) History: Previous history with customer (or customer’s Sourcing practice) can be a big help in deciding margins. Has customer always insisted on lower price? Or if his main concern is quality then we can charge more? Rating scale is based on customer favorability, from 1 to 10. If favorable then higher Marks (for no information we can give 5 marks). Weight = 20%

CHECK LIST (TO BE ANSWERED) BEFORE DECING THE MARK

Is customer price sensitive?

Is it on tender basis / negotiations possible after giving first quote?

Have we given discounts to the customer in the past?

So formula for calculating OM

= a/10 * 35% + b/10 * 35% + c/10 * 15% + d/10 * 15%

= (a * 0.35) + (b*0.35) + (c*0.15) + (d*0.15)

---------------------------------------------------

10

This method is to decide our target margin for an RFQ (not individual parts). And then individual margins have to be decided on Value Addition basis.

2) Deciding FP: Deciding FP means putting premium on factors of production. Firm needs to know what its costs are and accordingly should put margin on different factors. By theory, we have 4 factors of production: Land, Labor, Entrepreneurship and Capital. But as land and entrepreneurship are common across all proposals, hence we need not worry about them while pricing. So we will concentrate on labor and capital only. A product cost can be broadly divided into 2 parts:

i) Raw material (RM) (includes related overheads)

ii) Value addition (VA) (includes related overheads)

so, Total cost (TC) = RM + VA

RM is directly related to Capital or investment made. VA is directly related to labor. So when we put margin on total cost we are in effect putting margin on our capital and labor resources. Let’s see what happens when we put flat margin (present pricing method) on TC,

FLAT Margin = 50%


Observations from above table:

I. For Part no. A, both labor and capital have been equally compensated (Mar/VA = ROI)

II. For Part no. B, job consumes more labor and less capital, hence ROI is better than Mar/VA

III. For Part no. C, job consumes more of capital as compared to labor and hence Mar/VA is better than ROI.

Now let’s add real constraints to this system, assuming

Capital available = 500

Labor available = 500

No. of Jobs possible Net profit

Job A 500 / 75 = 6.67 1000

Job B 500 / 100 = 5 750

Job C 500 / 100 = 5 750

In this situation, one can take up 6.67 A type jobs or 5 B type jobs or 5 C type jobs. Naturally since absolute margin is same, doing more no. of jobs will result in more profit. Hence job- A optimizes the use of given resources. (all the rest combinations result in less than optimum use of resources) Now we can say that successful implementation of flat margin system is based on following assumptions:

a) Equal capital and labor resources availability

b) Job will consume equal or almost equal quantities of both resources.

And in all other cases wherever job consumption is different for capital and labor, system will have less than 100% utilization. Now let us see what happens if we have input resources in some other ratio. (other than 1:1).


As we can see from above cases, in case of one resource being less than other, doing jobs which use constrained resource more efficiently give more utilization and profit. In other words we would like to execute orders which require less of constraint resource. Hence pricing should encourage customers to give orders which are high on non-constrained resource (Job A in CASE:2 and Job C in CASE: 3). This is possible when we have different margins for different factors of production.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Analyzing Mar/VA & ROI




In above method (previous blog) we saw that if we price product based on margin on value addition, it aligns marketing with production. (i.e marketing what is more profitable to produce).

Now let us revisit the same table with different point of view,

Product RM VA TC M P Abs. margin Mar/Va ROI(Mar/RM)
  A      10  40 50  50%  100  50            125     500
B 40 10 50 50% 100 50 500 125
Now if I have Rs. 100/- to start my business, then I will be able to do 10 A kind of jobs and make 500 as profit, while in second case I will be able to do only 2.5 B kind of jobs and make 125 as profit.

This point of view gives us totally different kind of picture as we saw in last blog.

Any production system has 2 kind of constraints: Capital and Labor.

In first method we saw labor as constraint, priced on that basis and derived conslusions based on that (which favoured jobs involving less labor content). And now we are taking capital as constraint and doing the same exercise. But in reality we have both constraints. They cannot be taken in isolation.

In this light, lets redefine our objective:
(previously we defined it as maximising profit)



Now let us define our variables first, before starting analysis,





1) First let us see the impact of varying margin on Mar/VA and ROI while keeping VA % constant.

Following graph shows the linear variation in both the measurements:

Mar/VA = c1 * m / (1 – m)
ROI = c2 * m / (1 – m)
where c1, c2 are constants.


2) Now let us keep margin constant and vary VA as a percent of TC.

Following graph shows the inverse (non-linear) relationship between the 2 ratios.

Mar/VA = c1 / (c2 – RM) [= 1 / (1-x)]
ROI = c3 / RM [= 1/x]



From above we can see that in an RFQ, if we keep overall margin constant than different parts will have either high mar/VA or high ROI, depending upon their VA (or RM) content.

3) Our aim is to maximize both ratios. If we define a function which is equal to product of both ratios and then try to maximize it, we may get some method to maximize profit and ROI.

f = Mar/VA * ROI
= {(TC* m) / [(1 - m) * (TC – RM)]} * {(TC * m) / [(1-m) * RM]}
= square [(TC *m) / (1-m)] / [RM * (TC – RM)]

Again we can try to maximize above function

- with respect to margin, keeping VA% constant
- with respect to VA%, keeping margin constant

a) VA% constant
f = c1 * square [x / (1-x)]



b) m constant
f = c1 / [RM * ( c2 – RM)]
= c1 / [x * (1-x)]







Sunday, June 21, 2009

Value addition based pricing

Presently most of companies (especially in manufacturing) have total cost (TC) based pricing method. It is same age-old formula, which puts margin or markup on TC. For eg.,

                        Price (P) = TC / (1- M) where M is margin percentage)

[1] TC can be divided into 2 components: - raw material (RM) and - value addition (VA), which also includes all overheads

absolute Margin (M) = P - TC or in other words margin is premium over total costs which we are charging to our customer for adding value to raw material.

Before going further lets have few facts, objectives and assumptions; Fact: Every company has fixed manufacturing capacity Company objective: To maximise profit Assumption: Company faces infinite demand for its products

Now problem with TC based pricing is it does not tell us how to differentiate between 2 orders. For eg. Lets assume that a company is producing two products A & B,

         Product    RM      VA      TC       M      P       Absolute margin
A 10 40 50 50% 100 50
B 40 10 50 50% 100 50

From above table, if a company is facing A & B orders, it may consider both orders equally profitable. If criteria is margin percentage or even if absolute margin, both orders fare equally. But are they so? Consider margin per VA, (money earned on work done) for both products, for A it is 1.25 while for B it is 5. In above method, VA for first part is 300% more than in second part and still company is charging same margin. In simpler words, A spends 4 days in manufacturing, eats-up resources and generates same amount of money as that of B, which spends only 1 day in company (assuming 10 VA is equal to one day).

From company’s point of view, it would like to have more of B as with fixed capacity it will be able to do more no. of projects (=100/10= 10 B type orders) and hence total profit will be (50 x 10 = Rs. 500 for 100% utilization) But if it is stuck up with A type orders, it can do only (=100/40 = 2.5 no. of orders). In this situation it will earn net profit of (50 x 2.5 = Rs. 125 for 100% utilization).

From Customer’s point of view, assuming he is making rational choice; he would like to place those orders with us for which we are providing more value for less money. So based on present pricing method, he will have more tendency to place A type orders with us. Also in cases of multiple part no. in same RFQ, he can choose to give us those parts for which we are adding more value for less money.

Doubt 2: Why do we need to change margins depending upon complexity/easiness of order and big/small size of order?

1) Complexity/easiness of order: - Before giving this logic, one would like to raise simple question,

For a processing department, which one is more costly? a) an hour of work for an simple order or b) an hour of work for a highly complex order Well answer is both are same. It is because whether simple or complex, we are comparing one hour of job.

So parameter for comparing complexity of job is no. of hours taken. For a complex order, no. of hours taken will be more than simpler job and hence cost will go up. This fact gets accounted in cost estimation by coating department, so why do we need to put extra margin for complex job?


2) big/small size of order: - First of all one needs to question basic assumption behind lower margins for higher orders. Common sense says that one needs to give benefit of lower costs to customer, if he gives us larger orders. Now what are these benefits consists of: a) less raw material price b) less mnfg. Cost. c) overheads amortized over larger population

And one DOES pass on all these benefits to the customer!! All of these factors are covered in total cost. Sine glass cost is less and one is not taking any benefit of it and charging customer the same cost what we got from supplier. Due to learning curve effect, company is taking less time to produce same no. of objects and hence it is estimating less no. of hours for the job (again passing on the benefit of reduced process cost to customer). Overheads will be less because of larger base and again all overheads are passed to the customer. All in all, company passes all the benefits of mass production to customer even without thinking about it.

On other hand company is still paying to production worker for his effort. Margin is premium charged on effort. So if one is still making same effort why should one ask fewer premiums for a job? One would rather do other jobs which are paying higher premium for an hour worked.

Point is that by reducing margins for larger quantity orders companies are giving double benefit to customer and which need not be given (other than due to external factors like competition etc.)

Followers