Thursday, July 16, 2009

Analyzing Mar/VA & ROI




In above method (previous blog) we saw that if we price product based on margin on value addition, it aligns marketing with production. (i.e marketing what is more profitable to produce).

Now let us revisit the same table with different point of view,

Product RM VA TC M P Abs. margin Mar/Va ROI(Mar/RM)
  A      10  40 50  50%  100  50            125     500
B 40 10 50 50% 100 50 500 125
Now if I have Rs. 100/- to start my business, then I will be able to do 10 A kind of jobs and make 500 as profit, while in second case I will be able to do only 2.5 B kind of jobs and make 125 as profit.

This point of view gives us totally different kind of picture as we saw in last blog.

Any production system has 2 kind of constraints: Capital and Labor.

In first method we saw labor as constraint, priced on that basis and derived conslusions based on that (which favoured jobs involving less labor content). And now we are taking capital as constraint and doing the same exercise. But in reality we have both constraints. They cannot be taken in isolation.

In this light, lets redefine our objective:
(previously we defined it as maximising profit)



Now let us define our variables first, before starting analysis,





1) First let us see the impact of varying margin on Mar/VA and ROI while keeping VA % constant.

Following graph shows the linear variation in both the measurements:

Mar/VA = c1 * m / (1 – m)
ROI = c2 * m / (1 – m)
where c1, c2 are constants.


2) Now let us keep margin constant and vary VA as a percent of TC.

Following graph shows the inverse (non-linear) relationship between the 2 ratios.

Mar/VA = c1 / (c2 – RM) [= 1 / (1-x)]
ROI = c3 / RM [= 1/x]



From above we can see that in an RFQ, if we keep overall margin constant than different parts will have either high mar/VA or high ROI, depending upon their VA (or RM) content.

3) Our aim is to maximize both ratios. If we define a function which is equal to product of both ratios and then try to maximize it, we may get some method to maximize profit and ROI.

f = Mar/VA * ROI
= {(TC* m) / [(1 - m) * (TC – RM)]} * {(TC * m) / [(1-m) * RM]}
= square [(TC *m) / (1-m)] / [RM * (TC – RM)]

Again we can try to maximize above function

- with respect to margin, keeping VA% constant
- with respect to VA%, keeping margin constant

a) VA% constant
f = c1 * square [x / (1-x)]



b) m constant
f = c1 / [RM * ( c2 – RM)]
= c1 / [x * (1-x)]







No comments:

Post a Comment

Followers